Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one, Little Everyday Luxuries may earn a small commission, and it costs you nothing extra. How that works.
I own two bottles of olive oil most of the time. One is a large, inexpensive bottle I use for everything: sauteing vegetables, greasing a pan, the daily workhorse. The other is smaller, a good one, the kind with actual flavor, meant for finishing a dish or dipping bread. For years, that second bottle came out almost exclusively when someone else was eating with me.
My own solo dinners got the workhorse oil, every time, without exception. Not because the good oil was too expensive to use casually. Because somewhere along the way I’d decided the good oil needed an occasion to justify itself, and my own Tuesday dinner didn’t qualify as one.
The bottle that sat there for a year
I actually tracked this once, not on purpose, just by noticing. I’d bought a nice bottle of olive oil as a small splurge, the kind you drizzle over a finished dish rather than cook with, and it sat in my cabinet for almost a year, half full, because I kept “saving it.” Saving it for what, I couldn’t have told you. A dinner party that happened maybe twice that year. A guest who might appreciate it. Anyone, basically, except the person who was eating dinner alone in that kitchen five nights a week.
By the time I finally used it up, some of it had probably lost a little of its brightness just from sitting that long. The good oil, saved so carefully for an occasion worthy of it, had spent most of its useful life going quietly stale in a cabinet.
An ingredient you’re saving for a better occasion is an ingredient that’s aging while you wait for permission to use it.
What changed when I started using it on myself
I moved the good oil to the front of the cabinet, next to the stove, where my hand would find it without thinking. The first time I drizzled it over a simple plate of white beans and greens, just for me, on an ordinary weeknight, it felt slightly indulgent in a way that made me pause. Then I ate the beans, and they tasted noticeably better than they would have with the everyday oil, and the pause started to feel unnecessary.
Nothing about the meal was elaborate. Beans, greens, a little salt, good oil on top. But that oil is the difference between a dish that tastes like something you made because you had to eat, and a dish that tastes like something you made because you wanted it to be good. And I’d been reserving that difference for guests almost exclusively.
Where else this shows up
- The good salt, flaky and specific, saved for company instead of finishing your own eggs with it.
- A nicer vinegar or citrus, kept in the back of the fridge for a recipe that never quite arrives.
- Butter you actually like, versus the plainer stick you use for your own toast.
- Fresh herbs bought for a dinner party, while your own meals get the dried version from the spice rack.
The pattern is the same across all of these. The better version of the ingredient gets reserved for an audience, and your own solo meals get whatever’s left, whatever’s cheapest, whatever doesn’t need saving.
Ingredients don’t know who’s eating them
This is the part that seems obvious once you say it out loud but somehow isn’t obvious in practice. A good olive oil tastes the same whether it’s drizzled over a dish for six people or a dish for one. It doesn’t hold back its flavor because the audience is smaller. The only thing that changes is whether you decide to use it.
Once I actually thought about it this way, saving the good oil for company started to look less like thoughtfulness and more like a habit of ranking my own meals below everyone else’s. The oil wasn’t waiting for a better occasion. I was just not treating my own dinner as one.
This isn’t about spending more
I’m not suggesting you need to buy expensive ingredients you can’t afford, or keep two tiers of everything in your kitchen. Plenty of people only own one olive oil, and that’s fine too. The point isn’t the price tag. It’s noticing whether you already own something nicer that you’re rationing away from yourself specifically, and asking why.
If you do have a “good” version of something sitting in the back of a cabinet, waiting for a guest who might not come for months, that’s worth a second look. The oil is aging either way. It might as well be aging into a better dinner for you.
If you only do one thing
Move your good olive oil to the front of the cabinet, next to the stove, where it’s the easy reach instead of the special one. Use it on your own dinner tonight, even if it’s just beans and greens. Let it be for Tuesday, not just for company.
